Edit: Thank you, everyone, for providing such great information! Truly, thank you!
I’m looking to buy someone a set of good cookware. Hopefully, I’ll have them to gift in time for Christmas. My kitchen consists of a pot, pan, and a rice cooker (probably all from Big Lots or something), so I’m in over my head here.
In talking to people IRL, I’ve been told Amazon is not a good place for a quality set - which I believe based on mixed reviews of my recent purchases and my own lack of knowledge on what makes a good set. I was also told to search antique stores and consignment shops for pieces. So, I’m doing that without much luck as, again, I’m just out of my depth and it’s possible it will take much longer to find enough pieces to make a complete set (between 5 and 9-ish).
Does anyone have recommendations for what I should look for in a good pot/pan? Or, what are some solid brands that someone who loves to cook would be proud to own?
I’m not sure what is a good budget. Is anywhere between 500 and 1000 USD a good start?
Thanks for any advice you can give.
https://madeincookware.com/products/carbon-steel-frying-pan/12-inch
carbon steel which is the same thing but lighter and better suited for flattops
their steel cookware is awesome too
So, I have an inherent bias… I inherited my grandmothers Le Creuset dutch oven that she bought in the 50s. It’s still usable, so I built out a full set around that.
Problem: Le Creuset is STUPID expensive.
But here’s the secret… Find an outlet store near you and sign up for their email list.
They will regularly offer sales from 30% to 70% off.
https://www.lecreuset.com/outlets.html
They also regularly run “Factory to Table” events in certain cities.
Build your own set currently up to 30% off:
https://www.lecreuset.com/buildaset
Spend $200, Save 20%
Spend $500, Save 25%
Spend $1000, Save 30%
Use Code BUILDASET at checkout
I just knocked out this set:
Dutch Oven
Skillet
Saucepan
Braiser
Cassadou$1,460 -30% = $1,022…
My set, grammas is the 70 year old pot with the loop handle in the middle.
Foodporn:
Goddamn they’re gorgeous
Do you really need a set?
Starting with 9 inch frying pan should do the trick.
Lodge is a classic and wont break the wallet.
I would agree with this. Build your kitchen ware as you need it. Also, maybe check out carbon steel. Seasons like iron but isn’t as heavy. deBuyer makes some good ones that are preseasoned with beeswax. A bit more expensive than a Lodge pan, though.
Honestly, I would steer clear of sets and go for nicer individual pieces, as you would knives. A skillet, one or two saucepans, and a pot (with lids for all) will get you very far in a kitchen.
I don’t recommend cast iron grill pans, they’re a pain to clean for no real benefit aside from pretty grill marks.
I don’t know if they will be a good choice for where you live, but look up “Sur La Table”. They’re a high end cooking supply store from my area and they do ship. It’s going to be pricier than Amazon, but they only sell good stuff.,
Lodge is an American manufacturer of quality cast iron cookware. Buy what you need and read the “care and feeding” insert, then follow it.
You don’t need anywhere near $500 for a cast iron pan. I bought one on clearance from Kmart 15 years ago and it’s still cooking meal for me. It was probably $30 full price. It’s literally just a pan made out of cast iron. That’s all any of them are.
It’s more important that you take care of the pan, than what the price point is. Sure, you could spend an obscene amount of money on one, or three pans. But if you don’t take care of it it’s a waste no matter what.
You’ve received a lot of good answers and I don’t have much to add regarding manufacturers. Just a little warning towards the ultra cheap models. I once bought a big, BIG enameled pot for about 60€ in a supermarket because I needed something bigger in an Airbnb and I planned on using it after my vacation. That thing had a ridiculously thin bottom and bowed under heat, making it unusable on my induction stove.
I’m a sucker for good pans and pots, so my collection consists of Le Creuset, Staub, Skeppshult etc. But they’re pricey. You’ll never have this problem though.
Lodge isn’t really a thing over here, so I have no clue about their quality. But I guess they’re good, given the praise they receive.
I’m not sure what is a good budget. Is anywhere between 500 and 1000 USD a good start?
I mean, you can definitely get really nice stuff for that price. But it’s also overkill. Get yourself a nice set of Lodge equipment and some chainmail “sponges” for cleaning.
Le Creuset is also a good brand for a few more buc
Don’t use the chainmail on Le Creuset if it’s enameled though.
Lodge cookware is fine and cheap, I have a few sized pans from them acquired over the years and are still going strong, my only complaint is that the handles on them are very short. I also have a no name random cast iron skillet I got at big lots like 15 years ago that is also just as good as the day it was purchased. You don’t need to break the bank on getting cast iron pans—they are literally just a hunk of iron.
You should however figure out why you want cast iron. It is true that it is basically indestructible, but it has certain properties that can (slightly) affect cooking (specifically it retains a lot of heat for a long time and also heats incredibly unevenly).
Unclad stainless steel is basically the same as cast iron in that it doesn’t have artificial coatings and is nearly indestructible, but also heats faster and more evenly, is lighter, but doesn’t retain heat as well.
But seriously a 12 inch lodge pan is like $20 bucks and is basically all you’d ever need to cook most things
Also biggest advice: you dont need to baby your pans, just cook in them regularly and clean them afterward—they are at the end of the day giant hunks of metal that are heated.
I got the Amazon set a few years ago for my wife and she loves them. They work great as long as you treat them well. If you don’t already know, cast iron needs some extra love, so make sure you read up on that, or you’ll ruin even the best cast iron.
Be careful getting second hand, make sure to do lead tests of anything you buy before you use it for food.
I’ve had two Lodge fry pans for twenty years. Zero issues. $20 each.
I got this Lodge set plus an extra 10.25" skillet. I also got silicone handle covers because I don’t like burning my delicate fingers🤌💅
That should be enough and under $150. If anything, get an extra 10.25" dutch oven/pot.
A bit of topic, but with the DIY getting more and more in style, I was wondering if casting your own pan is a thing.
It definitely can be done. You make a mold from sand.
But it’s tricker than it seems:
Thanks a bunch for the link! That was fun to watch!