Crossposted from HackerNews
- I should be shocked that eight cops looked at a picture of a black kid holding a bag of doritos in his hand and agreed that it was a gun. why am I not shocked? - “The AI gave just us go-ahead, boys. Open fire!” - That’s unironically already been happening in Gaza for years now, and will now happen everywhere Palantir is used. 
 
- I’m not convinced they looked at anything. The AI sounded the alert and they peeled rubber. - Minority report - Minority report had a specialist review the footage and present the case to - threetwo witnesses who teleconferenced in and- approved the arrestwitnessed the investigation before sending in the troops.- So this is not that dystopian cautionary tale. It’s worse. - Edit: re-watched the intro. The witnesses watched, but the police arrested the perp on their own accord. One of the witnesses is a judge though. So I guess it’s a pretty well supervised process. 
 
 
- It was in his pocket, the pocket bulge was picked up as a probable gun. 
- Its cops. They just saw a black kid and figured they could plant a dime bag or a toy train after the fact. 
- They probably just trusted the AI. Like everyone else is doing for some reason. 
 
- Doritos, This much flavor should be illegal. - You’re welcome lays, I’ll take $200k for the idea. 
- Shows the importance of having a human in the loop. - And since the police vetted the image properly they shouldn’t be afraid of publishing it, right? 
- In 2021, writer and game designer Alex Blechman inadvertently created a meme: - Sci-Fi Author: "In my book I invented the Torment Nexus as a cautionary tale."- Tech Company: "At long last, we have created the Torment Nexus from classic sci-fi novel Don't Create The Torment Nexus!"
 - AI is a big component of the new and improved Torment Nexus which is coming along nicely. 
- Essentially this AI is a racist markov chain that can be simplified: - Skin colour = dark -> something in his hand = true -> result = A WEAPON A WEAPON!!! - It is doing good work replacing the police’s job of racially profiling minorities. Very efficient. - It wasn’t even in his hand. - The crumpled Doritos bag in his pocket had been mistaken for a gun. - This was a good kid who crumbled up the bag and stuck it in his pocket instead of littering, and he gets traumatized by a bunch of cops for it. Hell, he could have lost his life if an acorn had fallen at the wrong moment. - Ah okay. - In protest, everyone in that school should walk around with rulers, wrappers, bottles and other things sticking out of their pockets to trigger the system. - For fucks sake in 2002 I and all the other FFA kids went to school with knives and/or multitools clipped to our belts. 
 
 
 
- Omnilert later admitted the incident was a “false positive” but claimed the system “functioned as intended,” saying its purpose is to “prioritize safety and awareness through rapid human verification.” - What?? How is it prioritizing safety if it did exactly the opposite and created an unsafe environment (a bunch of US cops with guns pointed at teens)? - Black kids aren’t supposed to feel safe. Safety is for everyone else. 
- That was the quote I was about to paste, like what the actual fuck? Traumatizing innocent teens is functioning as intended eh? Wonder how many of our tax dollars is going towards this? Actually I probably don’t want to know… 
 
- Could’ve been killed :( (Since they had guns drawn out) 
- Don’t worry guys, they’re only putting these AI cameras in literally every city and doing it in shady ways without anyone knowing. And false flags like this happen very frequently. 
- Student afraid to return to school after AI sends police after him - that is quite a 21st century title 
- Cops not thinking and reliant on system to judge is how we get to psycho pass timeline 
 
- Look out! He’s got a whole bag full of ninja throwing triangles! - its the same thing light yagami used to hide a tv, so he can MURDER people with the notebook. 
 
- I once mistook a bag of Doritos for the president of the USA…no, wait…it was a bag of Cheetos…wait, no, actually it was one Cheeto, one GIGANTIC Cheeto (I think?!) 
- … Why did dexerto file this under “Entertainment” - Arguably it is hilariously stupid. 
 
- I, and most everyone I know, would 100% be crumpling up chip bags into vague shapes of guns and making it a pain in the ass for them to keep checking. 













